Root beer, that wonderful drink
The types I've tried with comments attached (from glass bottles or on tap for authentic style)

IBC                            classic flavor
Stewart's                     classic flavor
Filbert's                       classic flavor (good from a keg or a bottle)
Druther's Black Cow    classic flavor
Hires                           classic flavor
Goose Island                classic flavor (very smooth slightly creamy taste) very good
Griffing's Riverside       classic flavor
Pirate's Keg                 classic flavor (black crud on bottle threads, I don't know why.)
Dad's Old Fashioned     classic flavor
Trader Joe's                 classic flavor
Virgils                          black licorice type flavor
Martha's Exchange       slight black licorice flavor, very little carbonation (On tap or in a Growler)
Natural Brew               unique blend of natural flavors
Blumer's                      good classic flavor
Journey's Desert Sage   unique light herbal flavor
Journey's Shenandoah  fairly strong sassafras taste
Berghoff                      sweet smooth classic flavor
Thomas Kemper          classic flavor
Dog n Suds                  fairly commercial flavor, but not joking about suds
Sprecher                      classic flavor with a touch of honey
Gray's                         taste of natural cane sugar with mild carbonation
Naturale90                   classic flavor
Old Tyme                    sweet classic flavor
Richardson's                sweet classic flavor
Iron Horse                   classic flavor
AJ Stephans                 slightly unique classic flavor
Lion Brewery               classic flavor
Mad River                   classic with touch of vanilla
Riverdale                     classic flavor
S&O'K                        classic flavor
Jones Soda Co.            classic flavor
Henry Weinhard's        good blend of gourmet flavors
Hanks                         fine classic flavor with gourmet accents
Roundhouse                robust cane sugar flavor (served at Walter Payton's Restaurant, my 34th variety)
Sleeping Radish           cane sugar flavor comes through
Kate's Corner              classic flavor
Route 66                     quality classic
Dream Diner               classic flavor
1950                           caffeine and poor aftertaste (flavor like a popsicle stick)
Boylan Bottleworks      refined classic flavor
Gale's                          rich sweet spiced flavor
Sioux City                    slight sasparilla taste
Big Daddy's                 sudsy original
Old Fashioned              soft sweet herb blend
Barq's                         commercial taste (contains caffeine)
Jumpin Johnny's           classic flavor with rustic hints
Spiker                          gourmet classic flavor
Two Bellies                  classic flavor
Michigan Soda Factory  classic flavor
Mill City                      aroma and flavor of honey and vanilla (my 50th variety)
Fitz's                           a fine classic flavor
Chowning's Tavern       sweetened with Virginia honey
Frostie                         classic flavor
Journey's Barleycorn     malty flavor
Jack Black's dead red    strong carbonation, low flavor and sweetness
Americana                   rich sweet cane sugar with additional natural extracts
Townsend Tavern        sweet classic flavor
Rock Bottom Brewery  sweet and smooth
X Root Beer Riot         herbal health beverage flavor (contains caffeine)
Bundaberg                   sweet and hearty with a touch of Australian Outback
A&W                          great classic flavor
Sonora                        smooth classic with a touch of honey
Howie's                       very sweet generic flavor
Journey's Great Northern  rich mix of natural flavors
Pompei                       fine classic flavor
Chug's Choice             unique flavor with plenty of molasses
Big River Brewing      Nashville's finest, a savory sweet flavor
the Brew Brothers      sweet and smooth classic
Great Basin Brewing   honey birch root beer
Tommy Knocker        maple and licorice flavors
Pearson Bros.             mellow classic
Rat Bastard                very sweet, sweetness covers over odd health ingredients
Abita                          tasty with cane sugar sweetener
Nutfield                      smooth generous head, sweet woody flavor
Milligan's Island           sweet classic flavor (my 75th variety)
Wild Oats                    classic with cane sugar
Tommy's Naked Soda  clear, vanilla with hints of sasparilla
Glacier Brewhouse      rich full flavor, spicy hints
Moose's Tooth            classic flavor with multifaceted depth
Snow Goose               strong spicy flavor with licorice
Great Bear                  black licorice hints, smooth generous head, Northernmost brewpub in USA
Myers Avenue Red      rich and sweet, slight spice from cinnamon balanced with vanilla
Virgils Bavarian Nutmeg  a slight variation on the rich original
Husker                        sweet with slight carmel stylings
Capt'n Eli's                  cane sugar sweetness, non-traditional assortment of spices including wintergreen
Flossmoor Station        sweet and mild
Bulldog                       savory vanilla flavor that lingers with subtle honey
Gordon Biersch           complex sweet flavor that is mixed to strength at the bar
Taylor                        sweet classic flavor with a hint of yeast
Glen Ellyn                  classic flavor
Briar's                        crisp classic flavor
Cool Mountain            sweet classic
Sparky's                     strong sassafras with bite
Wooley Bugger Grand Cru   herbal flavor of wild Montana
The Root Beer Stand   classic sweet flavor
1919                           robust with natural sweetening
Steap, Green Tea        herbal flavor with only mild resemblence to common flavors
Blue Sky, Encore         goes further out on the organic flavor edge than regular Blue Sky
Point Premium            label is more unusual than the beverage, but who has a cone head on their label?
Troop 3                      extremely potent home brew for a good cause (my 100th variety)
Cubby Bear                cool solace for those who are not Red Sox fans
Santa Cruz                 elixir for the naturalist inside
Baumeister                 classic flavor delivered by Wisconsin
Cott                           crisp classic
Dr. McGillicuddy's      vanilla with a crisp finish
SOHO Natural            natural NYC...hmmm? But not bad
maine root                  cane juice dominance
Saranac                      classic heritage
Breckenridge Brewery sweet and smooth, no respect-served with ice in plastic like a common soda
Squamscot                  straightforward taste with great history
CooperSmith's             bold herbal essence with overtones of anise
Harpoon                     complex flavors layered onto a regular soda
Twin Lights                an extremely kludgy presentation of a descent brew
Rock It                       pleasant sasparilla style blend of black licorice and mint highlights that make you sing
Mercury                     a wicked good cordial from the north shore
Polar Classics             bold in the basics

For those who are counting, that is 116 different root beers



An excellent source of a wide variety of root beers The Soda Shop
My root beer inspiration Dan Meier's Root Beer page
The Godfather of online root beer Anthony's Root Beer barrel

My Personal Collection


Home