Tailless Jet Flies Free with Novel Control Technique
David Williams and his team have demonstrated the first use of a novel control method in an aircraft with no tail.
While conventional aircraft rely on protruding fins to enable steering, a tailless design makes the body as smooth and sleek as possible, making it safer to fly in dangerous areas where radar scans the sky for sharp edges.
Eventually, this technology could be employed to make commercial airplanes more fuel-efficient by removing existing steering parts that create a lot of drag.
This design is possible because of an innovative system, active flow control, that steers the aircraft by blowing jets of air onto different surfaces of the aircraft body that correspond to which direction the aircraft is turning.
Williams, professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering at Illinois Institute of Technology, led a team of Illinois Tech students and collaborators in the construction of a jet that houses both conventional steering controls and a novel implementation of active flow control.
In October 2022 the group launched the jet from the Pendleton Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) Range in Oregon for two nine-minute flights that demonstrated the success of the system.
For each flight, one pilot launched the jet using conventional flight controls. Then, midflight, they switched control to a second pilot who operated the active flow control system.
In the first test, the team found that the active flow control system actually provided more power than had been predicted from wind tunnel tests.
“In engineering, it never works that way, you almost always get less than you were hoping for, but in this case, we got more,” says Williams. “The first day was very dramatic. It was very strong and very scary. If the jet gets too far over on its side, it could spin out of control. In fact, it did go over to 90 degrees, but it recovered.”
Once the pilot gained confidence in their ability to control the craft, they executed roll and pitch maneuvers to test the active flow control’s ability to steer the jet at steep angles.
An advantage of active flow control is that it has the potential to allow for maneuvers that are impossible with conventional controls, including very fast turns and the ability to fly at angles that would cause conventional controls to become ineffective.
Williams says the unexpected power of their system has increased his confidence that they will be able to do these more advanced maneuvers with this jet.
For their second flight, Williams reduced the power to the active flow control system for a safer, more stable flight, allowing them to collect more data about how the active flow control was operating.
The active flow control is implemented using a patent-pending Coanda valve designed by Williams and his students, and this was their first chance to show the design’s success on an aircraft.
Williams says the team will be conducting more flight tests, gradually building toward using the active flow control during takeoff and conducting more extreme control maneuvers.
“We’ve made the breakthrough that I was looking for,” says Williams. “Now future tests will start adding to the accomplishments and confidence in the airplane’s design.”
Williams says both undergraduate and graduate students have been essential to this project’s progress.
“There has been impressive dedication by the students,” he says. “They are getting real-world, hands-on experience in the conceptual design of aircraft and aircraft systems.”
Rosemary Johnson (AE, M.ENG. MAE 5th Year), who works on the project, says, “There is nothing quite like watching the aircraft you spent months laboring over pass you by hundreds of feet in the air. A successful flight is what makes all the crashes and lead time worth it. Getting to apply what I learn in class to a real, tangible project is very exciting and reaffirms for me every day that I’m in the right field.”
Nick Sadowski (AE, M.Eng. MAE ’20), who is currently a systems engineer at Raytheon Technologies, also worked on the project.
“The experience definitely shaped what I like to do,” he says. “In most undergraduate courses you’re working on problems where there’s a right answer. On this project, I had to learn quickly that there isn’t always a right answer, but you should be able to justify everything you do. It was a shift in mindset, and I think it’s been very helpful for me in being able to solve problems better.”
Williams is a member of a NATO working group that received the organization’s 2021 Excellence Award for its efforts in this area.
Collaborators from the United States Air Force Academy and Astrium also contributed to this project.
Disclaimer: “Research reported in this publication was supported by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under Award Number 19-SG2020-2-0046 and the Office of Naval Research under Award Number N00014-22-1-2552. This content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration or the Office of Naval Research.”
David Williams, “Illinois Space Grant Consortium,” National Aeronautics and Space Administration; Award Number 19-SG2020-2-0046
David Williams, “Finless UCAS Flight Control with Active Flow Control Effectors and Advanced Maneuver Development,” Office of Naval Research; Award Number N00014-22-1-2552
Photo: Professor of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering David Williams